There are
365 mi
from Rutherford, NJ to Tonawanda, NY
That's the driving distance. It would take 7 hours 35 mins to go from Rutherford, New Jersey to Tonawanda, New York.
The flight distance (direct flight from Rutherford, NJ to Tonawanda, NY) is 285.93 mi.
365 mi = 587.15 kms